Carlo Acutis was an ordinary Italian teenager from a Catholic family who was into computers and video games. He taught himself programming and web design and built a website dedicated to documenting ecclesiastical miracles. Carlo died from leukaemia in 2006 when he was only 15 and become a saint last year when his canonisation was complete, earning him descriptions like “the first gamer saint” and “the patron saint of the internet”.
The elevation of Carlo to the first millennial saint was not without controversy. An article in The Economist at the time, suggested that nothing in his short life really explained why he was to become the first saint of the 21st century. The process of his elevation was unusually quick and it seemed like the Church wanted his sainthood for its own symbolic reasons, even going so far as to - rather gruesomely - encase his body in wax moulded to his appearance.
The identity problem
Contemporary design identity is like institutionally imposed sainthood. Designers have become quite used to thinking of our role in terms of providing an ethical conscience amongst our colleagues. We are the user advocates, the humanists in the room, defending the good against the bad.
Earlier this year, Joel Lewenstein who rather self-effacingly does “Design @ Anthropic” suggested that designers own “should we” decisions. He wasn’t really using this phrase in any moral sense in the article. It was more like a version of the well worn Ideo phrase “how might we”, standing in for the possibility space of design.
But there was something that made me ponder it as a moral claim nonetheless. Perhaps it’s because I already feel worn down by the constant, unmerited virtue signalling of my profession. Designers are no more or less responsible for choices framed in terms of ethics than anyone else. We are not special in any moral sense. Nor are we more responsible in any common sense.
Don’t tell the design ethicists of course. Their roles depend on holding clear to their consciences so everyone else doesn't have to. Designers who position themselves as the ones who would never knowingly oversell a dark pattern unlike those bad designers who would. You can’t be a saint without sinners.
Now please don’t mistake my cynicism for a rejection of good design practice. I’m not claiming that the cataloguing of dark patterns is not a worthwhile pursuit or a valuable reference for anyone navigating the field of design. My beef is with the performance of ethical seriousness and superiority as a way of reinforcing a kind of professional design identity. A performance that is ultimately no good for the individual or the field.
The victimhood problem
There is an underlying assumption within user-centered design in particular, that users are victims of poorly designed systems and need to be rescued from technology by designers. This unstated belief - the victimhood trope - ignores the creative ways in which users incorporate technology into their everyday lives and is often blinkered to the wider social context within which technology can be used.
What the victimhood trope highlights is that designers tend to focus primarily on design-for-use, at the expense of design-in-use. Users are not the passive recipients of design whose needs must simply be understood and met. They are active participants in the design process who will adapt something for their own use in creative ways that cannot be anticipated.
Unchallenged, this means that designers can start to see themselves as necessary mediators by default, rather than being in service of the users, and when this is incorporated into professional design identity, user advocacy can become a form of paternalistic behaviour. A perception of user helplessness is what makes design heroism part of your design identity.
There is perhaps a blind spot here insofar as designers can readily spot patronising paternalism in products, but less so in the attitudes and behaviours that their own professional identity demands of them.
The structural problem
Whilst you will hear plenty of complaints about design not having a seat at the table in many organisations it also true that design has been subject to the kind of corporate courtship that gets the endorphins flowing. The decade of acquiring design firms in the 2010s and the accompanying value signalling of design capability may have passed us by but the afterglow of that courtship is still with us even if design has been largely domesticated.
This flattery allows us to overlook how design is used as a way to allow everyone else of the hook. If an organisation is practising design thinking and investing in design talent then they must be a “good” company. Let’s not the love in get distracted by any ethically dubious business practices, especially if they have a CDO, or better yet, a desinger-founder.
Design is structurally positioned for self-congratulation without accountability. If designers are the ethical actors in an organisation they feel close enough to power to feel consequential, but are actually far enough away to avoid any real consequence. The structural conditions that make this possible are the kind of moral laundering. The organisation gets its permanent sainthood in the form of a domesticated design identity while the actual work of design - like Carlo’s life - becomes largely beside the point.
In his book Against Identity, Alexander Douglas argues via Spinoza and other philosophers that identity as inherently defensive and constricting, requiring enemies and boundaries. It is identity as a container of moral qualities that must be resisted. The design profession needs bad design for good designers to exist. It must treat users as passive recipients to justify it’s interventions. And it needs unenlightened organisations to spread it’s gospel and sustain its moral identity. This isn’t a failure of design as such. The design profession is simply a victim of the same identity politics it wouldn’t fail to recognise and critique elsewhere.
Attitude as the alternative
Before design identity there was design attitude. There was something valuable there long before it got named and professionalised. A disposition towards the material world, a way of thinking about and embracing problems, a set of instinctual habits that develop over time and don’t depend on a particular self-image being maintained. Professionalism never wholly captured attitude. It just partially obscured it.
Its never been more important to recapture design attitude. A profession that cannot be honest with itself about where real agency lies, cannot defend itself against the commodification of it’s power. Worse still, we will be coopted into designing our own obsolescence whilst clinging to an illusion of importance that was never really ours to begin with.